By Simon Kershaw | Posted on May 09, 2025 4:30 PM
What Broadway Shows Have Sold Out Of All Their Tickets This Month: Sold-Out Shows For May 2025
What Broadway Shows Have Sold 100% Of Their Tickets This Month?
Sold-Out Broadway Shows For May 2025
The following Broadway shows are playing to packed audiences and have sold out every single ticket at every performance - this may indicate that their ticket pricing may increase as producers increase ticket prices. This perfect-score ticket sales performance does not mean they are actually the best shows on Broadway, just that they sold all their tickets.
1 - Good Night, and Good Luck
Stage Production of Clooney's Oscar-Nominated 2005 film, Set in the 1950's As Murrow Goes Up Against Senator Joseph McCarthy During The McCarthy Hearings
Average Ticket Price: $304.71
Top Ticket Price: $795.00
Seats Sold: 12511
Gross Ticket Sales: $3,812,165.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
2 - Othello
A timeless tale of jealousy, manipulation, and tragic downfall unfolds once again on Broadway, but this time with powerhouses Denzel Washington and Jake Gyllenhaal in the lead roles
Average Ticket Price: $387.03
Top Ticket Price: $897.00
Seats Sold: 8344
Gross Ticket Sales: $3,229,396.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
3 - Wicked
The prequel of The Wizard of Oz where Elphaba becomes the Wicked Witch of the West. Based on the 1995 original novel by Gregory Maguire.
Average Ticket Price: $138.17
Top Ticket Price: $352.00
Seats Sold: 15408
Gross Ticket Sales: $2,128,874.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
4 - The Picture Of Dorian Gray
One-handed stage adaptation of Oscar Wilde’s novel where Gray's pursuit of eternal youth corrupts his soul; his portrait ages and decays while he remains physically unscathed
Average Ticket Price: $199.61
Top Ticket Price: $497.00
Seats Sold: 6033
Gross Ticket Sales: $1,204,238.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
5 - Just in Time
Chronicles Bobby Darin’s journey to stardom, his turbulent personal life, marriage to Sandra Dee, and timeless songs.
Average Ticket Price: $206.35
Top Ticket Price: $496.50
Seats Sold: 5685
Gross Ticket Sales: $1,173,110.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
6 - John Proctor Is the Villain
Play that explores high school students grappling with gender, power, and morality, paralleling themes from Arthur Miller's The Crucible, amid personal revelations.
Average Ticket Price: $95.14
Top Ticket Price: $375.00
Seats Sold: 6270
Gross Ticket Sales: $596,511.00
Percentage of Tickets Sold: 100%
Sold-Out Status Is Not What It Used To Be
Even though the above Broadway shows have sold every single ticket that were available, making the show effectively sold-out, this does not mean that they are the most popular tickets on Broadway. That criteria is defined by the gross tickets sales value, instead of percentage-sold tickets.
A Broadway show may give many tickets away for free (or practically nothing) to get classified as "sold-out" - which then allows them to advertise the show as "sold-out" to increase ticket sales on the back end of the run. Its disingenuous at best, and deceiving at worst - but a lot of Broadway shows still do it.
See all Discount Broadway Show tickets
